She's baaaaack! Harry Potter fanatics and butterscotch lovers have been waiting for this moment for a few months...This perfectly sweet and chewy cookie was on our main menu for quite a while. When we took it down, you all made sure we knew it had to come back! We thought that fall would be the perfect time to snuggle up with a Butterbeer Cookie and warm cozy drink. This is the baker's dozen cookie for our 2021 Fall Box, so make sure to add a Fall Box to your cart to get your hands on this fan-favorite!

*Click here to grab a Fall Box!