She's baaaaack! Harry Potter fanatics and butterscotch lovers have been waiting for this moment for a few months...This perfectly sweet and chewy cookie was on our main menu for quite a while. When we took it down, you all made sure we knew it had to come back! We thought that fall would be the perfect time to snuggle up with a Butterbeer Cookie and warm cozy drink. This is the baker's dozen cookie for our 2021 Fall Box, so make sure to add a Fall Box to your cart to get your hands on this fan-favorite!*Click here to grab...

This cookie is our take on a classic S'more with graham cracker pieces, marshmallows, and Hershey's chocolate all piled into our classic chocolate chip cookie base. Oh my word, don't even get me started on how amazing this cookie is heated up! Nothing reminds us more of fall than bonfires on chilly nights, which of course requires s'mores! Make sure to snag a 2021 Fall Box to get your hands on this returning flavor...*Click here to grab a Fall Box!

This pillow soft cookie is very similar to our Whipped Cream cookie with a new pumpkin flavor & seasonal spices. We would never take away Whipped Cream without adding another supremely fluffy cookie to our menu, and this is it! This cookie has the perfect balance of seasonal sweetness and unique texture. It's a must-try!*Click here to grab a Fall Box!

This is a fantastically different cookie with an incredible flavor and texture. Picture melted butter with honey mixed in to create savory honey butter that is poured over fresh baked cornbread....in cookie form!!! Sabrina here, y'all this is seriously my all time favorite cookie, hands. down.*Click here to grab a Fall Box!